I know Steve (TCU Reefer) tried it on his ASM's Sedra pump said:It came apart because when trimming the mesh around the center (where the ceramic shaft is) I may have trimmed off too much. I made sure the second time that the mesh was very well secured with zip ties and it's still holing up after running rof about a month.
This is a cheap and easy mod to do and my skimmer is working better than ever.