Ok, I finally found a picture that actually looks like the same coral, including color. I do believe it is a Chili Cactus Coral or Strawberry coral, this is what the site had to say: Nephthyigorgia sp
Common Name Chili Cactus Coral
Also known as Strawberry Coral, Red Chili Coral
Fast Facts The Also Known as the Strawberry Coral, Nephthyigorgia sp are some of the only corals available to the trade in a bright red color. Non photosynthetic, does not require light. Do not place directly under bright lights, place in lower areas of the tank or in caves, out of the direct path of light, preferably in shaded areas. Generally easy to care for, it fares best under medium to high water current, does best with alternating/pulsating/changing water movement. Does best with supplemental feeding with foods such as liquid phytoplankton, but don't over do it. Most species
Thank you everyone for your aid in trying to Identify it. And special thanks to Marine Center for their pic and description that cinched the deal.