Wes is exactly right. Somewhere on this site, I documented the PAR measurements between spider and lumenbright reflectors, and it is truly over 300% brighter. When I measured the light in the Toadstool leather with my former lighting, it was 145 PAR. With the new reflector it measured 444 PAR. That was a massive increase all of a sudden.
What I did with my lighting is:
Week 1 - 2 hours per reflector
Week 2 - 2.5 hours per reflector
Week 3 - 3 hours per reflector
Week 4 - 3.5 hours per reflector
Week 5 - 4 hours per reflector
Week 6 - 4.5 hours per reflector
Week 7 - 5 hours per reflector
Week 8 - 5.5 hours per reflector
Week 9 until now - 6 hours per reflector
Now the first week of only getting 2 hours per reflector, I ran the first one from 1pm to 3pm, the second one from 3pm to 5pm and the third one from 5pm to 7 pm. This gave me 6 hours a day to look at my tank. Then as the times increased, I gradually overlapped them somewhat and here's what my tank's staggered lighting looks like:
http://www.reefaddicts.com/content.php/120-Staggered-Lighting-why