On Ken's suggestion, I ordered a dozen of these algae magnets. They got here (Plano) overnight UPS. They're not bad. Not the strongest, but he's right, gluing two of them might work. I've included a pic of the product.
Also, they only mention glass on the packaging. They look pretty rough and might scratch Acrylic. However, I think it would be easy to change the "inside" media and use something less abrasive for acrylic. All in all, for a $1 each, it's hard to go wrong.
BTW, shipping was $7 (ouch) but it's sorta heavy. Still $1.50 each.
Larry