Drain Noise

Chino

Membership Expired
I recently acquired a 20g tall nano drill 1 3/4" with a 1" buik head with a 10g sump. The overflow box and bulkhead is from here http://www.glass-holes.com/Super-Nano-con-Dientes-Overflow-Box-Complete-Kit-ghsndienteskit.htm which is rated for 300gph. Im brand new to keeping drilled tanks/plumbing and Im having trouble with the sound of water cascading down the drain pipe. It's very loud and wondering if there's anything I can do besides completely changing out the drain plumbing. I've done tons of research on things that could possibly work but no luck so far.

From the hole is a 1" bulkhead which starts with a 90 degree elbow that drops straight down 1" pvc about 2ft into a union which then drops down 1ft more with two 45 degree elbows down 1" below the waterline in the sump.

The return is a rio 1100 which pumps into a 1ft vinyl tubing then into 1" pvc approx. 2ft up into (2) 90 degree elbows back into the DT.

Things I've tried:
1. Restricting the flow of the return simply by covering 20-80% of the return nozzle. Also with a sponge. Still has loud draining sound in drain pipe with no difference. This tells me I do not need to install a valve in the return?
2. Restricted the drain same as above also with a sponge. The sponge actually eliminates the water draining sound for a bout 30 seconds until the overflow box started gurgling. Took a look inside the overflow box and its actually not getting enough water? How is this possible. I would think that the opposite would happened if Im restricting the drain from the sump. If I cover up about 80% of the drain from the exit in the sump the same happens only difference is some water spits out the airline tubing from the bulkhead elbow. I understand that putting a valve on the drain is an accident waiting to happen unless you have an emergency drain which I do not have. My question is, since Ive already manually restricted the drain with 50/50 success is it even necessary to try?
3. I heard that the end of the drain should only be 1-2" below the waterline in the sump. Mine was about 6" under the waterline so I cut it to 2" as some recommended and no luck. But now I have the sound of large bubbles gurgling in the sump. Even worse.

Do I need to just re-do the drain plumbing all together? With a dual drain? Is the noise from the straight 3ft drop with the current design? If so, will making a drain with a few twists and turns make a difference? Im not a very good DIY person and have zero experience with plumbing but Im willing to give it a try. If you have any suggestions and or advice I would be very appreciative. This noise has been driving me nuts for the last 3 days and is causing me to delay starting up the tank. Had to cancel an order on some LR. Had no idea the noise was going to be this bad. Especially for the bedroom!

Here are some pics:
img2524w.jpg
alt="">

img2525y.jpg
alt="">

5Ib5Ee5Hb3L93N83Hbc8q11308e24390119f4.jpg
alt="">

v6lmxk.jpg
alt="">

5L65I35Ma3E53Gd3Kdc8q1a18d7d2586a147d.jpg
alt="">
 
How long has the tank been set up? Many times you will experience loud drains in the beginning before the slime builds on the inside of the pipes. This may or may not be what is causing your issues, but it will generally quiet down over time once things have been running for a little while. Your drain section is rather large for the single drain pipe, so you may try to isolate the drain line into one corner and put some rubble rock in there to break up the bubbles as well.
 
@ctaylor81 wrote:
How long has the tank been set up? Many times you will experience loud drains in the beginning before the slime builds on the inside of the pipes. This may or may not be what is causing your issues said:
Thanks for the quick reply Chance. I forgot to mention that Ive only been running a leak test with fresh water. I also have heard that the plumbing may need to just "break in". I guess I can try that but will have to get the tank running once the tank is running I will have to break it down if I need to redo all the plumbing. I hope slime is the true issue.

With regards to the drain section. Would you recommend me connecting a 45 degree elbow at the end and face it towards the corner?
 
I'm by no means a plumbing expert, but my first thought when reading was, 'how high is your water in the overflow'? Then I later read you don't think it's high enough. I may have missed it, but have you tried restricting the drain flow a little bit, or increasing your pump size? (this may be completely wrong, im just trying to add ways to increase the volume inside the overflow box as maybe more water draining might decrease the noise from excess space or water to splash around) Hope it helps
 
What's up John. Thanks for your reply man. As I mentioned above, the weird thing is, I did try manually restricting the drain with my fingers and a sponge just to see what would happen. When doing so, it eliminated the drain noise but then the overflow box water level became lower causing the overflow box to gurgle loudly. Weird right? I would think it would "overflow" because Im restricting the drain. Therefore, I solved one problem but acquired another.

The only thing I havent tried is using a stronger pump for the return. Everyone has told me Im getting enough flow already with the rio 1100. Wouldnt it be funny if it was the retrun pump? Haha. The overflow box is rated for 300gph but I heard having it at 200 is recommended. I have no idea what that means. Wish I had a mag 5 or a rio 1400 laying around.

@ReefJunky wrote:
 
Looking good, and very similar to my 20! [smilie=wink.gif] Fresh water will be noisier than salt, and it will quiet down a lot once some slime has built up. I would recommend giving it at least a month of running with salt before you start messing with it.
 
Titus! Thanks. Yes! Very similar to your 20. I noticed your drain is also a straight drop to the sump. Im guessing this has nothing to do with what's causing the noise. Well, I figured out if the overflow box is full the sound goes away. Im guessing im not getting enough flow? What kind of maxi jet are you using? I think Im gonna order a stronger pump or maybe get one off here to see what happens. I have a rio 1100 which the Flow Rate (GPH) @ 3 Feet: 236. I think I need something to push it to 300gph to match the overflow. What do you think? But the thing is, Glass holes recommends 200gph to keep the noise down? Im confused.

Or I can just go ahead and set it up to slime it up :)

@Titus wrote:
 
I ended up going with a QuietOne 1200 for my return. It is a pretty low flow... Less than I expected. You don't want so much flow that your overflow starts to fill as that means it is having a hard time keeping up with the return. That can lead to flooding . Do you have the overflow with the lid? That may help reduce noise.

Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S 4g using Tapatalk.
 
Following as im having same issues. Mine is 2-1in overflows with 2-1in returns using a mag 9.5. My overflow is the 2-1in that converts into 1-1.5in about a quarter of the way down. But most of the sound is in the overflow box and water running down the tube. Might just need a bigger pump not sure as mine is rated for 1200gph.

Chino I have a mag 3 which might work for you if you wanted to trade for something PM me. Its almost new condition.
 
@Burbarry wrote:
Following as im having same issues. Mine is 2-1in overflows with 2-1in returns using a mag 9.5. My overflow is the 2-1in that converts into 1-1.5in about a quarter of the way down. But most of the sound is in the overflow box and water running down the tube. Might just need a bigger pump not sure as mine is rated for 1200gph. Chino I have a mag 3 which might work for you if you wanted to trade for something PM me. Its almost new condition. said:
Thanks for the reply Burbarry. That's very odd. I have a good feeling that I just need a bigger pump *crosses fingers*. I just literally purchased a rio 1400 on ebay. It's rated 420gph and 290 @ 3ft head pressure. If it doesnt work out I will contact you regarding the mag 3. Thank you.

A rio 1400 was the original pump that was used with this setup from the original owner so I hope it solves the noise.
 
Change the outside part from an elbow to a Tee fitting, running North/South. You will need to put a cap on the top of the Tee and drill a 3/16" hole. You are basically building an external Durso standpipe on the drain line.
 
@Burbarry wrote:
Good luck with your venture. Im thinking about trying a mag 12 or 18. said:
Thank you. I will keep you updated. Good luck if you decide to upgrated to a mag 12 or 18. I certainly hope that we both figure this out.

@Marc wrote:
Change the outside part from an elbow to a Tee fitting said:
Thank you for your reply Marc. Im going to try the rio 1400 pump that I just ordered and if it's not more flow that Im needing then I will definitely take the extrenal durso route. I've been advised serveral times in the past few days to build a durso. Thank you and I will keep you updated as well.
 
that elbow at the top should have a hole drilled in it and a plastic tube pushed in it. Thats how my glass holes 700gph overflow is set up and its fairly quiet but not silent
 
@DaveG99 wrote:
that elbow at the top should have a hole drilled in it and a plastic tube pushed in it. Thats how my glass holes 700gph overflow is set up and its fairly quiet but not silent said:
Thanks for your advice. It actually does have a hole drilled in it with a plastic tube pushed in it as seen in the 3rd pic on my original post. It's black on black so you mightve missed it. Here it is again.

5Ib5Ee5Hb3L93N83Hbc8q11308e24390119f4.jpg
alt="">


I've actually tried adjusting the tube as well with no luck.
 
I barely see it. Is the tube clear of any obstructions?
 
@Marc wrote:
Change the outside part from an elbow to a Tee fitting said:
Hi Marc, I did this but still get a lot of bubbles coming from the north end of the tee. I have no cap on it but a foam to keep it from splashing out. The drain is 1" PVC and the return is a Mag 7. I replaced the return PVC to tubing because it was louder than a dishwasher but still having issues with drain. Below is a pic and I may have more detail within my build log.
[attachment=1]ImageUploadedByTapatalk1350316153.241684.jpg[/attachment]
[attachment=0]ImageUploadedByTapatalk1350316202.739328.jpg[/attachment]

Any suggestions?

Thanks,
Matt


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Top